32 people found this review helpful
2 people found this review funny
2
1
Recommended
0.0 hrs last two weeks / 48.1 hrs on record
Posted: 27 Oct, 2024 @ 12:44am
Updated: 27 Nov, 2024 @ 11:15am

Silent Hill 2 (2024)
Memory frights the colours of my mind

The Silent Hill 2 remake delivers an immersive, spine-tingling experience that not only honors the 2001 classic but enhances it in ways that make it essential for both longtime fans and newcomers to the series. Developed by Blooper Team, this remake captures the unsettling atmosphere and psychological horror that made the original a masterclass in suspense while adding modern technical advancements and gameplay refinements.

Pros:
1. Graphical and Audio Upgrades
The remake’s visuals are nothing short of breathtaking. Built on Unreal Engine 5, the graphics enhance Silent Hill ’s fog-drenched environments, with photorealistic character models, stunning lighting, and richly detailed textures. Fog and shadows are used brilliantly, making you feel genuinely trapped in a haunted, living town. The audio has also been modernised, with Akira Yamaoka's iconic soundtrack remastered, giving it an atmospheric punch that complements the game's eerie world.

2. Enhanced Character Depth and Storytelling
Silent Hill 2's storyline was already a benchmark for psychological horror, and the remake has done a fantastic job expanding on it without detracting from the original’s emotional weight. Voice acting, motion capture, and subtle tweaks in dialogue and character interactions add layers of depth. James Sunderland’s character feels more human, making his journey through grief, guilt, and fear even more relatable and compelling.

3. Improved Combat and Exploration Mechanics
The original is sometimes critiqued for its clunky controls, combat and dutch camera angles by modern audiences, and the remake aims to address this by introducing a smoother, more intuitive style of combat and movement. The controls are responsive and enhance immersion, making the gameplay flow better and exploration more satisfying. The camera system has been overhauled to provide a more cinematic, close-up experience while avoiding disorienting angles. Encounters with creatures like Pyramid Head and the Lying Figures feel visceral and terrifying due to the improved mechanics.

4. Faithful to the Original's Atmosphere
The remake understands that the real horror of Silent Hill is in the details. Whether it’s the ambient sounds, unsettling silence, or disturbing visuals, Blooper Team keeps true to the haunting, oppressive atmosphere. The fog, abandoned buildings, and grotesque creatures all contribute to a palpable sense of dread that keeps players on edge without over-relying on jump scares.

5. Replay value with Enhanced Endings
With updated visuals and new animations, the multiple endings offer new perspectives and subtle narrative shifts. This keeps players invested and offers fresh incentives to replay the game to experience every twist and turn. Easter eggs and new hidden items in certain locations also encourage exploration and reward meticulous players with additional lore.

Cons:
1. High System Demands
The Unreal Engine 5 graphics look stunning but come at a cost. Players with older hardware might experience performance drops, especially in high-fidelity settings. On consoles, though optimised, occasional frame dips can be noticed in intense foggy areas.

2. Pacing Adjustments May Not Appeal to Everyone
Some fans might feel that certain pacing tweaks in the remake reduce the slow-burn tension of the original. While these changes streamline exploration for modern audiences, they can make sections feel slightly faster, which could disappoint players who loved the deliberate pacing of the classic. In other areas, like the puzzles, have been expanded on significantly which could lead longtime fans and newcomers alike believing that the game is deliberately lengthening its running time but the puzzles are so much more detailed and satisfying to solve this time around.

3. Familiarity May Impact the Surprise Factor for Veterans
Although the remake stays faithful to the original, this means that returning players may anticipate scares and narrative twists. The remake does add some new elements, but those deeply familiar with the original might find fewer surprises than they hoped. Some veterans may also be surprised at the significant amount of combat the player will have to experience in order to get through this story. While many enemies can be run past and avoided, there are situations in the game where combat is unavoidable so temper your expectations.

Final Verdict
For me personally, this Silent Hill 2 remake is a triumph and my personal GOTY for 2024, beautifully blending nostalgia with modern innovation. Blooper Team’s remake has set a new standard for psychological horror remakes, showcasing that a faithful recreation can still feel fresh and exhilarating not to mention completely anxiety-inducing (the new Toluca Prison section is going to shred even the hardest of nerves). This remake doesn’t just rely on high-definition graphics; it revitalises the emotional core of Silent Hill 2 while amplifying its horror and immersiveness for a new generation. For fans and newcomers alike, Silent Hill 2 (2024) is a haunting, unforgettable experience that cements itself as a new horror classic that sits comfortably alongside the original.

After all the tiresome negative online discourse surrounding the game by "fans' , some who seem hellbent on wanting to see the game fail because Konami named Blooper Team as the development house and that didn't seem to sit well with a lot of fans (due to Blooper Teams spotty track record) but Blooper Team absolutely nails it here. They clearly understood the assignment and then went above and beyond that was expected of them where you can see the love the team has for original source game because they have poured their heart and souls into this one and it shows. Well done Blooper Team, talk about a flex and a serious level up.

One word or phrase to sum up the experience
Anxiety-inducing and nerve-wracking and definitely not for the feint of heart

Performance/Bug related incidents
There are traversal stutters unfortunately as you move into new areas (this seems to be an Unreal Engine 5 thing. Performance was a bit spotty at launch but the recent patch seems to have fixed most of this

Similar to games
Resident Evil 2 Remake, Alien: Isolation, The Evil Within 2

Rating ★★★★★★★★★★
https://steamproxy.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=869453048
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award
5 Comments
Zednaught 31 Oct, 2024 @ 5:47pm 
Thanks for a good review. Honestly, it convinced me not to get the game. I'm sure that it will be great for first time players, but as someone who still remembers the original pretty well after all these years, I don't think the story could really hook me since it's so similar to the original.
The Dogfather 27 Oct, 2024 @ 6:05pm 
Thanks for the comment Jack. I look forward to hearing what you think of it in the future.
Crash_Khan 27 Oct, 2024 @ 5:41pm 
Great review! I will definitely give it a go in time.
The Dogfather 27 Oct, 2024 @ 4:34am 
Klaus I dare you, I double dare you in fact :steamhappy:
Klaus 27 Oct, 2024 @ 1:12am 
Hey, really great review! I'm not usually a horror fan, but you've described the game so excitingly that I almost want to give it a try. Your impressions of the atmosphere, the graphical improvements and how they have deepened James' story - it all sounds pretty gripping. The description of the fog and the enemies in particular makes your nerves flutter just reading it!

And your fair pros and cons make it really tangible for someone like me who isn't easily enthusiastic about horror. Who knows, maybe I'll dare to give it a try at some point - your review would definitely be a good way to convince me!