147 people found this review helpful
4 people found this review funny
Not Recommended
0.0 hrs last two weeks / 47.7 hrs on record (44.0 hrs at review time)
Posted: 20 Jun, 2016 @ 3:03pm
Updated: 21 Jun, 2016 @ 1:03am

I made a review before this a few days into early access, and if you want a TL;DR I'll paraphrase one of my previous lines - buy into it if you're fine with being an alpha tester. I am. It's flawed, but fun.

So as Robot Arena III rolls into a full release, it must be considered that the devs themselves say that it's more of a tactical move to bring it out of early access, what with the Steam summer sale approaching fast. But I'm not here to knock their sales strategy.

Having a binary recommendation option is tough for some games; this is one of them. To recommend it right this moment as a full release title would be to grossly overrate it's current quality and depth of content. The physics aren't all there as a simulation game, with bad collision physics in certain circumstances and with certain components. Components can still be placed anywhere without any boundaries. The career mode does not reset when all of the tournaments have been finished. There's a bug where the camera won't stop moving up or down in the bot lab after battling some AI opponents that should have been swatted by now.

But to not recommend it would be to downplay the monumental effort the devs have been undertaking in the last 4 weeks to improve the game. The first day of early access the game was considered 'full', and it was a mess. You couldn't even build a wedge shaped robot because every robot had box collisions. Now you can. The biggest drive motors would make your robot flip on the spot like one of those toy backflipping dogs unless it weighed as much as a star. Now they don't. Weight classes are back. Should all of these things been in the game on day 1? Absolutely. But they also could have just dumped the game there and then and moved on. They haven't. I respect that.

They have good ideas. The 5 layer chassis system is great for rounded shapes or crafting detail. Being able to move components after placing them is one of the best quality of life improvements they could have made after RA2. Someone on Gametechmods[www.gametechmods.com] figured out how to mod the game, even if it's crude at the moment, so a modding community is imminent. Robot Arena III will be great. It's just not 'great' this second.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award
10 Comments
Gruisman 19 Apr, 2019 @ 4:50am 
I want to thank the creators of this game for bringing out this terrible game and i'm glad you got away with this scam. Somehow you still get people buying this crap even though you wont even make it remotely playable compared to robot arena 2. P L E A S E R E M O V E T H I S G A M E F R O M S T E A M. They dont deserve to get any more money from this
Callumari 12 Nov, 2018 @ 9:23am 
i can't bear it RA2 and RA3 don't work i swear to god but it might just be my computer
RedSawn 15 Jul, 2018 @ 11:47am 
Go to Gametechmods, mate. They'll have what you seek.
Kye Wilson2000 15 Jul, 2018 @ 11:09am 
the worst part is they have completley removed robot arena 2, when i went to go and see if the old game was still around whenever i found a link it would lead straight to robot arena 3 so as far as i can tell there is no way of finding the original if someone knows where i can find it please respond
RedSawn 21 Jun, 2016 @ 1:07pm 
They engaged more during the first week, right now it's more like they're buckling down and not saying much except in the most pressing circumstances, something like silent watchers. I still have no doubt they are passionate - they've surveyed the fan community/GTM figuratively and literally before and now, the Lone Saw AI opponent is based on a community meme bot, we've come up with ideas that get added in the next patch several days later..
GiftingPhoenix 21 Jun, 2016 @ 12:58pm 
Maybe, but comments like these are still very helpful.

When I buy games that have no cards for a high price, I have high expectations.

Ever since Reddit found that some devs will post fake positive reviews, I take more notice when a popular game has as many complaints as this one.

Another thing I take notice is many game devs will post and respond to comments, sometimes just to say they're glad you enjoyed the game. I find it unimpressive for games that have so many complaints and no dev responses that they're working to fix it ASAP.
RedSawn 21 Jun, 2016 @ 12:16pm 
Perhaps later. I still think it'll eventually win out, it's just it's currently undercooked. It was raw on first release
Rhyno Seacrest 21 Jun, 2016 @ 12:06pm 
At the moment, it really looks like RA2 blows this out the water. Shame, too, since I really wanted to buy this.
RedSawn 21 Jun, 2016 @ 12:37am 
I do enjoy it, but the total package is still RA2. I was actually going to make this updated review positive a few days back but that was still as an early access game.
GiftingPhoenix 21 Jun, 2016 @ 12:07am 
Thanks for the heads up, was super excited to seem a game like this floating around. Until I saw the price, no cards and the game I got for the price.

The reviews just seal it, even the positive ones trash talk it.