37 people found this review helpful
4 people found this review funny
5
Recommended
0.0 hrs last two weeks / 81.2 hrs on record
Posted: 30 Jan, 2018 @ 7:03am

Having beaten this game, and all of the DLC, I can strongly say that this is among the best written game series that I have ever played. The characters are well developed, the score very well done and placed, the dialog very well written, and the ending exceedingly perfect. You are missing out on a lot of the story, if you do not play the two Burial at Sea additions.

The not being able to save bothered me at first, but I found that it actually helped to keep me from forgetting important immersion points, from how it begins each chapter. The method is actually an improvement, in my opinion, as opposed to the save anywhere option. The challenging difficulty was fantastic. I had immense trouble at some points, making it require actually strategy, instead of just banging your head against a wall until you get through. While that might work at times, and the Clash in the Clouds addition does feel like that, this game benefits the person who uses a methodical approach, rather than guns blazing.

I have read some have become of sudden experts on quantum physics, and they dismiss the ending of the main game. From Doctor Who, Star Trek, Time Machine and many other movies who have done such ideas of paradoxes, there is no straight answer to how it could or could not work. I did feel a bit at odds with the ending, despite it being very well done from its own individual point, but having playing Burial at Sea 1 and 2, I can now say the writers of this game, and the additional content, are simply amazing.

While I hear rumors of a fourth addition to the Bioshock series, and I hope that it does come to fruition, this series could end respectfully here.

In short, this is a must play game, if nothing else, for the story. You will need to have played the first Bioshock to get the fullness of the story, though Bioshock 2 is just filler, it is a worthy part of the series as well, if you enjoyed the first and third part of the series.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award
30 Comments
Old Man Gamer (OMG) 22 Dec, 2022 @ 9:43am 
I was able to see the story connections and understand much of the story, without it being spelled out for me. I dislike when stories over-explain things, and treat the audience like idiots. So, for me, this was perfect. The reason that Elizabeth had powers was not just because she lost her finger in that other time line though. It was because that finger piece lost kept a connection, which caused her to have the ability to cross them, eventually at will. This idea is a bit of a stretch, but works well enough. What gets me wondering, is why the twins had never thought of just getting that finger tip back. In theory, that would have ended her abilities, which is what they wanted, ultimately. Due to her being the one causing the chaos that they wanted ended, that had them being tortured in their own loop of existence. They created this paradox with their research, which was used in what was originally a reach for science, and ended up causing much more than expected.
Old Man Gamer (OMG) 22 Dec, 2022 @ 9:36am 
The leaders were both egomaniacs. They did not consider others, and forced their idea of perfection. Sure, in their mind, they were the good guys. The story shows that well. However, in reality, they created a dystopian world, where poor were slaves, rich were addicted to the power and surgeries, as well as attention. They were a selfish and self serving society in every way. To use little girls to make the drug, and to create slaves to conduct experiments, do the labor to keep the cities going, and mutate some slaves to remove their free will, to be in service of a particular service. These things are not the action of good people.
Old Man Gamer (OMG) 22 Dec, 2022 @ 9:36am 
The people of rapture and any place of this nature, they are a cult in a closed community. They were not healthy and friendly, as it would seem. The audio bits explained that plenty. You can listen to the various version of additional exposition from those and other collectibles. If anything, it was fascist and totalitarian. You either followed in line and obeyed, or your neighbor would turn you in, to avoid being cohorts. This was not just a political thing, however.
Old Man Gamer (OMG) 22 Dec, 2022 @ 9:30am 
Booker's timeline up to that point existed, because Elizabeth still existed. As long as she existed, the paradox remained. It was not until she ceased to exist, that he would effectively cease. In the DLC, it explains that this is the last Booker, and this is the last Elizabeth. This ended the paradox and closed the loop. The final action was giving the brainwashing quote that would get things in motion. Being that this is time travel and parallel realities, there is no way to do it without some plot issues, as all of this is without any real definition. I find that the story handled this well, though.

The powers given to the people were indeed a drug. It is what drove people crazy. The entire game, from beginning to end, explains this, and says to what extent people would go to get more of it. Including the killing of little girls, which was the reason of the big daddy creations.
v00d00m4n 21 Dec, 2022 @ 9:17pm 
Another video about early versions https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJHaP3Ovjcc
v00d00m4n 21 Dec, 2022 @ 9:15pm 
Or when you said drug you was talking about DLC? Anyway main game behavior of NPC was far fetched and ubelivable, and had no explaination because initial explaination and design of corrupt supe-position npcs was cut in final game and replaced with regular people that still had AI of corrupt NPC from earlier builds. This is one of many example of why Bioshock Infinite is a mess.

I have one very detailed vidoe about BIoshock Infinite development, but its in russian, however Youtube have autosubtitiles with translation so mostly you will understand it. Watch this video, you will understand what i mean when you will see all versions of Infinite and how it changed.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AvWvaiWqwNA
v00d00m4n 21 Dec, 2022 @ 9:09pm 
And about 2-1 year prior release people went crazy because they all used alternate universe travels and got merged with too many alt versions of themselvess and became sorta-of superposition corrupt version of themselves that could not handle multi-personalities in a single body and got insane. They also head deformed bodies that was like few bodies melted together in earlier version of game, and in later version they sort of look like in some static field with some stutters with shaky models that supposed to represent multiverse bodies merged together in 1 universe. Unfortunatally this was completely cut in final year edition of game, and people in game was left unreasonably agressive and they kinda forgot to motivate ir properly through story.
v00d00m4n 21 Dec, 2022 @ 9:08pm 
Drugs? Where did you get this idea? There was not any drugs in Infinite! Majority of people was just regular joes, families with kids and so on. There was no any drugs in game. Even vigor was not drug, and it was not even used by much of people. Whole agression of people in game was not caused by any drugs, it was just forced. Actually is a big mistake and result of change of concept in a rush in last year. I mentioned that before that levine did not have solid vision of game and it evolved constantly into something different.
v00d00m4n 21 Dec, 2022 @ 9:01pm 
Cult? Cults are everywhere they just offer different ideas, but core of them is the same. Modern pseudo-democracy also is form of cult. Even liberalism if form of cult. Communism is cult. Capitalism is cult. Everything is cult, everything has some kinds of faith and some form of leader or leader representtaive they worship.

So there is nothing wrong about that in case of Comstock his cult was just different from cult of Sodom bellow, he just offered people a choice and a lot of people choose his cult over cult of sodom bellow.
v00d00m4n 21 Dec, 2022 @ 9:01pm 
There was nothing fascist about Comstock, it was tradiional empire the rejected so called "democracy" which gave people illussion of control but only changed dynasties to bumch of reach and usually criminal businesmen who pretends to be elected but in fact are getting selected in inner circles and then playing roles on public. This is what Comstock called a sadom bellow, he wanted to keep it old fashion way, and created his own monarchy in a place where nobody can find him and start a war against it - in a sky. And he clearly cared for his people.