it;s to mouch at once... i would remove the santa hat and tie. maybe try making the bells apper and disaper in the yellow cloud. idk for sure need less detail.

This is the only item in the workshop I have ever voted on
and of course I voted yes

Sincerely, thank you so much for taking it in good faith too! There's ways of informing others of your perception without detracting from both effort and concept. Keep up the amazing work, and if decide to make any changes, may it be by your hand as you see fit. Have a great day! <3 @Cheesypuff

@AscenDandy In my years of workshopping thats the 1st time someone has given such an amazing critique. Thankyou

I want to just start by acknowledging the effort and things this effect concept does well. I read the concept as you designed (In the bio) and absolutely agree with the thematic elements and the details behind the selective colouring.

This is a really gorgeous effect, but I feel that the festive elements may be somewhat burdensome, and very noisy, detracting from the other elements of the effect, and what it delivers on. Potentially the bow tie/bells, or the Santa hat could be removed. Not to revise your intentions, because I absolutely see the concept working by giving all of the elements the right room to shine.

Thanks for reading anyways, I commend the effort that's went into this, and I hope you find my critique to be in good faith. It is only based on my opinion after all.

two words CHRISTMAS MOON two more words YES PLEASE

I can honestly say we need a Cloudy Moon Christmas Unusual effect. Feels like some Nightmare Before Christmas effect I need! Good stuff. :)

Thank you!
We are all very happy with how it came out and are happy to see others are liking it just as much!

Congrats on getting in