For you guys who don't care about how to find the secret and just want get the achievement, just go to the next section of the guide "‘Daddy's Secret’ Fast version" to find out how to do it.

So a while ago ClusterPuck 99 got a secret achievement added which was was talked about in a update:


The first person to find the secret and get the achievement was going to be awarded with a $50 Steam Gift card. Since the update got released only roughly 0,5% of the players have managed to solve it.

I snooped around in the game to see if I could find a clue and managed to find some stars in "Nick Madonna's" section in the "Credits" (highlighted in the red circle):


I figured it was a code, but didn't know what to do with it.

After playing "Challenge Mode" I noticed that after winning every other challenge (Challenge 1, 3, 5, 7 and 9) there was a different coloured star in the top right corner with a button input next to it.

Here are the screenshots in order:






So what we've gained from this is that:
If we go back to the "Credits" section on "Nick Madonna" we can see that the stars colours are in this order:
If we use the button inputs that was next to each individual star in "Challenge Mode" in this order we get this code (controller only):

Down, A, Down, Down, Y, X, Left.

Down, X, Down, Down, Triangle, Square, Left.

For some reason the combination didn't work for me when I used the D-pad, so if it doesn't work for you either then use the joystick for down and left.

If you enter this code whilst being in the "Nick Madonna's" section in the "Credits" we solve the secret achievement "Daddy's Secret" and get rewarded with this picture whilst some mariachi music plays:


If the achievement doesn't pop up even though you did it correctly and got the picture, just restart the game and it will pop up once you start the game again.

P.s. If you somehow don't recieve the achievement even though you did this correctly you might have to do the challenges 1, 3, 5, 7 and 9 in "Challenge Mode"

I hope this guide was useful. Good luck!

Go into "Credits" on main menu and then click on "Nick Madonna".

After that enter this code (controller only):

Xbox controller:

Down, A, Down, Down, Y, X, left.

Playstation controller:

Down, X, Down, Down, Triangle, Square, left.

For some reason the combination didn't work for me when I used the D-pad, so if it doesn't work for you either then use the joystick for down and left.

By doing this code whilst being in the "Nick Madonna's" section in the "Credits" we solve the secret achievement "Daddy's Secret" and get rewarded with this picture and whilst some mariachi music gets played:

If the achievement doesn't pop up even though you did it correctly and got the picture, just restart the game and it will pop up once you start the game again.[/b]

P.s. If you somehow don't recieve the achievement even though you did this correctly you might have to do the challenges 1, 3, 5, 7 and 9 in "Challenge Mode"

Good luck and have fun!