Store Page
Magical Diary: Horse Hall
All Discussions Screenshots Artwork Broadcasts Videos News Guides Reviews

Magical Diary: Horse Hall

Store Page
Magical Diary: Horse Hall > Guides > Jill of Trades's Guides
29 ratings
Secret Society Achievement (Spoiler-free)
By Jill of Trades
Like a moth to a flame, like a wasp to a rose. Is that you? Then come join our Secret Society!!!
   
Award
Favorite
Favorited
Unfavorite
Created by
Jill of Trades
Online
Category: Secrets, Walkthroughs
Languages: English
Posted
Updated
27 Dec, 2012 @ 3:08pm
6 May, 2019 @ 5:57pm
2,643 Unique Visitors
19 Current Favorites
Guide Index
Overview
Secret Society Achievement 
Tip Jar 
Comments
Secret Society Achievement
Requirements for later on:
Have at least -20 demerits and $5.
Do not have more than 0 points for all types of magic for Step 4.

1.Sept. 6 Ask her what she's doing. Virginia should pay Ellen. (This is to ensure you have a positive score with ellen for the step below)
2.Sept. 9 Get up by yourself. Refuse to take part. (Just to make the rest of the walkthrough easier.)
3.Sept. 26 Skip It.
4.Sept. 27 I don't want detention! (This will give you a total of -20 demerits to guarantee you for the upcoming event.)
5.Oct. 4 There's nothing wrong with that. Wait and see. (Another guarantee for the event.)
6.Oct. 8 Yes.
7.Oct. 11 Vote for Ellen.
8.Oct. 25 Give up Exam. (This will lead to -30 demerits. You must stay at -20 or over, so passing to gain a merit isn't an option here.)
9.Oct. 30 Just to avoid a negative point, select "Are you going to ask William out?"
10.Nov. 1 Let it go.
11.Nov. 9 All right.
12.Nov. 14 Stay Quiet.
13.Nov. 18 Yes. (You lose $5.)
14.Nov. 22 They should be punished. (This is another guarantee for the event.)
15.Dec. 2 For your schedule, DO NOT plan to Study or Sleep in! You can pass this exam. If Ellen speaks to you, "It's a magic exam." (Selecting "That's not fair!" will ruin the achievement.)
16.Dec. 3 If all is successful, you'll get an event. "Let it Happen." "Sneak out at night." "Yes."
17.Dec. 4 Don't Lock it.
18.Dec. 5 Any choice.
19.Dec. 20 No one. (Just for fun.)
20.Jan. 5 If all is successful, you become a member and get the achievement!

Credits:
Guide: Hanako
Simplified Walkthrough: MaronaPossessed

Using this guide on an external website? At least link back to this page! Thank you!
6 Comments
< >
Teksura 16 Oct, 2014 @ 2:48pm 
"Do not have more than 0 points for all types of magic for Step 4."

That just gets you expelled. What I did was take 2 classes, red and blue, and the rest was gym/study/rest.
Teksura 16 Oct, 2014 @ 2:35pm 
"Do not have more than 0 points for all types of magic for Step 4."

That just gets you expelled.
Jill of Trades  [author] 3 Jun, 2014 @ 6:58am 
Thanks Sexybutt
Prinny 4 Apr, 2014 @ 4:57pm 
if you never took any magic classes (only study, gym and sleep) you are expelled before the first exam. It is strongly suggested you get 1~3 in at least one or two of the magic type, as long as you do not have any spell learned you are fine. you cannot exceed 3 point in a single class (By that I mean taking a single classe of a single tpe will give between 0 and 3 points. you need 5 for the first spells of that color) So long as you attend one or two classes it should be fine.
Magical☆Melody 6 Apr, 2013 @ 9:25pm 
Is there a way to find out more about the society? Is this perhaps the conspiracy with Ellen? Would love to know more :)
just kidding 20 Feb, 2013 @ 5:24am 
At the Sep. 27, if you learned a little bit of every magic, then you have to choose Green on Exam, and this will still give you 10 demerits.