Actually loved it.

Pros -
New, fresh story.
Hilarious comedy throughout with lots of references to the show (and new stuff too)
Combat system.. I was skeptical at first but it grew on me.. makes the game more challenging
Lots of ways to change/improve your character unlike the first game
More freedom than the first game
Lots more special abilities outside of combat to help you figure out puzzles

Cons -
Black screen on loading the game. Had to hit alt+enter to put it into windowed
Turn based combat bugs and takes like a minute between turns sometimes, annoying.
Kinda linear, but didn't expect much else from this game
Could/should have been longer, maybe include (a LOT) more sidequests.. completed in 15hrs

Actually loved it. Pros - New, fresh story. Hilarious comedy throughout with lots of references to the show (and new stuff too) Combat system.. I was skeptical at first but it grew on me.. makes the game more challenging Lots of ways to change/improve your character unlike the first game More freedom than the first game Lots more special abilities outside of combat to help you figure out puzzles Cons - Black screen on loading the game. Had to hit alt+enter to put it into windowed Turn based combat bugs and takes like a minute between turns sometimes, annoying. Kinda linear, but didn't expect much else from this game Could/should have been longer, maybe include (a LOT) more sidequests.. completed in 15hrs