Red Dead Redemption 2 is a sprawling Western tale of loyalty, conviction, and the price of infamy, chronicling the inevitable collapse of a motley crew of Old West resisters fighting the slow march of civilization and industrialization. Set in Rockstar's most authentic and lived-in open world, there are so many things to do, so many people to meet, and so many places to explore that it's dizzyingly overwhelming. Red Dead Redemption 2 isn't just Rockstar's greatest achievement to date; it's a game so lacking in commitment that it's hard to know where to start discussing it.