Those are my opinions on Red Dead Redemption 2 and while I loved the first game, I found the sequel to be a mixed bag.
The main campaign is slow-paced and restrictive, and the hunger and stamina depletion system gets tedious. I also had issues with the weapon wheel and found the story to be uninteresting. However, the game is visually stunning and has entertaining side missions and characters. It didn't blow me away, but I'm glad I played it. Overall, I would pay its price rating, not including the online aspect.

The game world is vast and detailed, with a variety of landscapes and wildlife. The game also features a realistic hunting and fishing system, and players can interact with other characters in a variety of ways, such as through dialogue or combat. The game's attention to detail is impressive, and the game's physics and animations are realistic. The game's soundtrack is also noteworthy, with an original score that adds to the game's atmosphere.

One of the main criticisms of the game is that it can be slow-paced and sometimes feels like a chore to play. The restrictive movement and interactive points can be frustrating, especially when you just want to move on to the next mission. The hunger and stamina depletion system can also become tedious, as you constantly need to buy replenishment items to keep your character from slowing down.

The game's story, while well-written, is not as memorable as the first Red Dead Redemption. The cutscenes can be long and uninteresting, and the story's pacing can be slow. The game's missions are also generally uninspired, with many of them being just "shoot-out" objectives. There are a few missions that stand out, but they are few and far between.

In conclusion, Red Dead Redemption 2 is a visually stunning game with a vast and detailed world, but it can be slow-paced and restrictive. The game's story is not as memorable as the first Red Dead Redemption and the missions are uninspired. The game's attention to detail is impressive, but the game's restrictive gameplay and gradually draining story really hurt my experience. Overall, I would recommend the game with reservation and only if you are willing to invest time and patience.