Its a decent game, but it really could have been a great game. The characters had good progression but their stories made them boring, the main story was fine and the gameplay was fine. It just needed more polish in all areas and it would have been much better. And it needed quidditch. It was also a little jarring to have more diversity in 1835 (I think) than in the relatively modern era in which the books took place! But thats a standard fare with a modern game I guess.

Its a decent game, but it really could have been a great game. The characters had good progression but their stories made them boring, the main story was fine and the gameplay was fine. It just needed more polish in all areas and it would have been much better. And it needed quidditch. It was also a little jarring to have more diversity in 1835 (I think) than in the relatively modern era in which the books took place! But thats a standard fare with a modern game I guess.